Dissecting the Prompt

Rationale

The Dissecting the Prompt strategy is effective to use when introducing students to a new writing assignment. By having students annotate and discuss a writing prompt, this activity gives students the time they need to decode what the prompt is asking them to think and write about. You can also use this strategy to introduce an essential question for a lesson, unit, or course.

Procedure

  1. Prepare Prompt
    Print out a prompt or essential question in a larger font and tape it to the center of a piece of paper.
  2. Students Dissect the Prompt
    Ask students, in pairs, to dissect the prompt. As they read the prompt, direct them to make the following notations:
    • Circle words you do not know or understand in the context of the prompt.
    • Star words that seem to be the central ideas of the prompt.
    • Underline all of the verbs that represent what you, the writer, are supposed to do.
    • Cross out any extra information that does not seem specifically relevant to the writing task.
  3. Make an Initial Response to the Prompt

    Next, ask students to respond to and discuss the prompt using the Think, Pair, Share strategy. Individually, students should try to answer the prompt or essential question simply based on their “gut reaction” or personal philosophy. If possible, ask students to try to support their current thinking with an example from history or their own life. After a few minutes, ask each pair to share their thinking with each other. Finally, ask students to share a few opinions or ideas with the larger group. Tell students that their initial responses will evolve as they encounter new ideas and evidence in class.

  4. Record the Prompt

    Before moving on, ask students to write the prompt or essential question in their notebooks. As they have new thoughts about the prompt throughout the unit, they can make notes to themselves.

Related Content

Teaching Strategy

Think, Pair, Share

Facilitate thoughtful group discussions by having students first share their ideas in writing and with a partner.

Teaching Strategy

Evidence Logs

Use a graphic tool to help students centralize and organize evidence as they prepare to respond to a writing prompt.

Teaching Strategy

Journals in a Facing History Classroom

Create a practice of student journaling to help students critically examine their surroundings and make informed judgments.

Teaching Strategy

Two-Minute Interview

Students interview classmates to gather evidence and ideas about a topic as they practice being active listeners.

Search Our Collection

Everything you need to get started teaching your students about racism, antisemitism and prejudice.