Lesson 23 of 25
Duration:
One 50-minute class period

Confronting Genocide Denial

From the Unit:

Essential Questions

Unit Essential Question: How can learning about the choices people made during past episodes of injustice, mass violence, or genocide help guide our choices today?

Guiding Questions

  • What are the consequences of genocide denial?
  • How can public works of art commemorate difficult histories and be used as a form of civic and community participation?

Learning Objectives

Students will explore some of the causes and consequences of denying the Armenian Genocide and reflect on the role of public art to commemorate difficult histories.

Overview

In the previous lesson, students examined the purpose and meaning of achieving justice in the aftermath of the Holocaust. This lesson continues students’ exploration of the legacies of genocide by examining the phenomenon of genocide denial. Through an examination of the Turkish government’s official policy of denial of the Armenian Genocide, students will examine the consequences of denial, both for those directly impacted by the genocide and the wider public. They will explore how Los Angeles–area descendants of survivors of the Armenian Genocide have responded to efforts to suppress and deny this history by creating public art commemorating the genocide. Finally, students will consider how public art can serve as a tool to educate the public as they envision the creation of a mural documenting a historical event or injustice in their own community. While this lesson focuses on denial of the Armenian Genocide, denial of the Holocaust is also a phenomenon worthy of exploring with your students. See the Notes to Teacher section for suggestions and resources for addressing Holocaust denial.

Context

As he was planning how to rid Germany of Jews, Hitler asked, “Who, after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?”1 He was referring to the mass murder of over a million innocent Armenians by the Turks during World War I. Nearly 20 years after that genocide, the perpetrators, for the most part, had gone unpunished, the Turkish government denied these murders had occurred, and this tragic episode was largely forgotten by the media and those outside of the Armenian community.

To this day, the Turkish government continues to deny the occurrence of the Armenian Genocide during World War I. In Turkey, and the former lands of the Ottoman Empire, where the murder of more than a million Armenians took place, these events have never been officially accepted as true by the government. At the end of World War I, the three leaders most responsible for planning the destruction of the Armenians escaped from Turkey; though they were tried in absentia, they never faced punishment. One of those leaders, Mehmed Talaat, claimed in his memoirs that there were no deliberate plans to massacre Armenians. When those memoirs were published after Talaat’s death, they set the pattern for the arguments still used to distort the history: the false claim that the Armenians were traitors who deserved to be deported and who died as a result of a civil war in which both sides committed atrocities.

Within Turkey, individual citizens and scholars have acknowledged the genocide, holding academic conferences and organizing commemorative events. But despite overwhelming historical evidence, including primary sources, eyewitness accounts, testimony of perpetrators, survivor recollections, and physical evidence, the government of Turkey denies that a genocide took place. Those who deny what happened have used many strategies in their attempt to turn a historical fact into a matter for debate or even a myth. They have funded their own academic centers dedicated to spreading a revised and distorted history, and they have intimidated scholars who study and write about the genocide.

Some authors who wrote about the genocide have been brought to trial for insulting “Turkishness,” which is a crime in Turkey. Turkish officials worked to censor United Nations reports by blocking mentions of the genocide and by countering resolutions in the United States that would have recognized April 24 as a national day of remembrance of the Armenian Genocide. While some countries, including France and Germany, have officially recognized the Armenian Genocide, many others have not. Leaders of many countries, including the United States, have been reluctant to force Turkey to acknowledge the genocide because they don’t want to embarrass or alienate an important ally.

Denial has consequences. In 1998, more than 100 prominent scholars signed a petition outlining those consequences, which said, in part:

Denial of genocide strives to reshape history in order to demonize victims and rehabilitate the perpetrators. Denial of genocide is the final stage of genocide. It is what Elie Wiesel has called a “double killing.” Denial murders the dignity of survivors and seeks to destroy remembrance of the crime. In a century plagued by genocide, we affirm the moral necessity of remembering.2

In 2015, on the 100th anniversary of the genocide, journalist Raffi Khatchadourian described how denial of the genocide affects the Armenian community worldwide. He wrote:

Armenians continue to struggle with the official negation: to endlessly combat it is its own form of prison, but to try moving past it unilaterally, abandoning the horrific events of 1915 in the shadows of denial, is to succumb to willful blindness and injustice.3

Denial, he says, is not just an absence of truth but a “wounding instrument. And, after a hundred years of it, it is hard to feel Armenian in a meaningful way without defining oneself in opposition to it.”4

As students will explore in this lesson, descendants of Armenian Genocide survivors feel compelled to speak out against the Turkish government’s policy of official denial. Armenian American artists, from the Los Angeles–based muralist Arutyun Gozukuchikyan to the punk rock band System of a Down, commemorate the Armenian Genocide in their work and speak about the consequences of its denial. Their art functions both as a memorial to the genocide and its victims and as a form of civic participation and protest. It contains an important message for people outside Armenian communities, too. In response to the question of why recognizing the Armenian Genocide is important, historian Taner Akçam has argued:

One, to respect the victims, to accept their dignity and to give an end to their traumas. Second, it is very important for the reconciliation in a society, for the democracy and for the human rights. If a society cannot face its own history, it cannot establish a democratic future. And the third factor is, related to the second one, if you want to say the sentence “never again,” it can only be possible if society faces its past, its history. If a society, if a state, doesn’t acknowledge its wrongdoing in the past, this means there is a potential there, always, that it can do it again.5

Citations

Notes to Teacher

  1. Addressing Holocaust Denial

    Because it is difficult to address denial of the Holocaust and the Armenian Genocide with the nuance and specificity both topics deserve, we have opted in this lesson to focus specifically on denial of the Armenian Genocide. Nevertheless, despite the overwhelming breadth and depth of evidence documenting the Holocaust, some individuals, groups, and nations seek to minimize and distort the facts of the Holocaust or claim that it did not happen at all.

    You may want to extend students’ study of denial by devoting additional instruction time to Holocaust denial. The video Holocaust Denial, Explained (2:56), produced by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum (USHMM), provides an overview of Holocaust denial from historian Deborah Lipstadt. In addition, you may want to share with students the USHMM’s multi-part module on Holocaust denial. Students could explore the module using the following questions:

    • During the post-war period, what factors impeded a full reckoning with the crimes of the Holocaust?
    • What are the motives of those who deny the Holocaust today? What might Holocaust deniers have to gain politically or psychologically?
    • What role did the Nuremberg trials play in educating the public about the Holocaust?
    • How can a rigorous study of the history of the Holocaust provide a powerful tool to help students identify and confront Holocaust denial?
  2. Previewing Vocabulary

    The following are key vocabulary terms used in this lesson:

    • Participation
    • Memorial
    • Commemorate

    Add these words to your Word Wall, if you are using one for this unit, and provide necessary support to help students learn these words as you teach the lesson.

Materials

Activities

  1. Reflect On the Personal Impact of Denial

    Ask students to privately journal a response to the following prompts. Explain to them that they will not share their answers with the class:

    • Think of a time when someone wronged you and denied it. How did you feel?
    • How does someone denying that they perpetrated an injustice impact the target of that injustice?
  2. Explore the Consequences of Denial
    • Tell students that in class, they will be deepening their study of the aftermath and legacies of genocide by returning to the Armenian Genocide, which they learned about at the beginning of the unit. In today’s class, they will be examining why it is important to keep the historical memory of the Armenian Genocide alive and the consequences, for individuals and for society, of denying that it happened.

    • Play a clip from the video The Armenian Genocide (37:19–42:26), which explores some of the causes and consequences of the Turkish government’s policy of official denial of the genocide. Before students watch the clip, have them preview the following questions and take notes as they watch that will help them answer:

      • How do Turkish officials explain their position on the Armenian Genocide? What do they think happened in 1914–1915?
      • According to scholars in the film, what motivates people to deny that the Armenian Genocide took place?
      • What actions has Turkey taken to deny that the Armenian Genocide took place?
      • What makes denial possible?
      • What factors might make people willing to deny (or unwilling to challenge others’ denial of) a genocide for which there is overwhelming evidence?
    • Ask volunteers to share their responses and clarify any misunderstandings with students.
  3. Discuss the Role of Art as a Force against Denial and Forgetting
    • First, pass out and read aloud Confronting Denial of the Armenian Genocide through Art, which discusses how Los Angeles–area artists have used their art to foster public awareness of the Armenian Genocide, in direct contradiction of the Turkish government’s official policy of denial.

    • Then, in small groups or as a class, discuss the following questions:

      • The creator of the Los Angeles murals, Arutyun Gozukuchikyan, describes his role as “documenting” and “painting history.” How can art provide a window into the history of the Armenian Genocide that traditional historical accounts cannot?
      • How does the Turkish government’s official policy of denial shape how these artists view the purpose and urgency of their art?
      • How can commemorating the Armenian Genocide through art function as a form of protest and civic participation?
  4. Visualize a Mural for Your Community
    • Ask students to respond to the following prompts in their journals.
      • If you were designing a mural that educates your community about a historical event or injustice, which would you choose as your focus?
      • What designs or illustrations might you choose, and where would you place the mural?
      • How would your mural serve as both a memorial and a tool to educate community members and visitors and spark important conversations?

Assessment

  • To check students’ understanding of the material in this lesson, listen to the class discussion in Activity 3. Students should be able to articulate why it is important to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, as well as the consequences of denial both for Armenian communities and for the wider public. In addition, you can assess students’ final journal reflection to evaluate their understanding and their engagement with the concept of art as a tool for civic action and historical education.

  • As a way to assess students’ engagement with the material in this lesson, you might ask them to expand their journal reflection into a formal proposal using the prompt below. You might also consider turning this proposal into a larger project that involves researching their community to learn more about its history and where they might place their mural.

    Imagine that you are submitting a grant proposal to design a mural that calls attention to and educates your community about a historical event or an injustice. Write a short proposal in which you explain the design of your mural, and include a description of its significant historical figures, people or groups, landmarks or other objects, and any text that you plan to include. Consider how your mural might serve as both a memorial and a tool to educate community members and visitors and spark important conversations.

Extensions

  1. Explore Holocaust Memorials and Monuments

    To extend students’ examination of the role of public art in shaping historical memory, consider using the lesson How Should We Remember? from the resource Teaching Holocaust and Human Behavior. In this lesson, students both respond to and design Holocaust memorials as they consider the impact that memorials and monuments have on the way we think about history.

Unit

Introduction
Holocaust

Get Started

Learn about this unit's alignment to California state standards and find other helpful information before you begin teaching.

Lesson 1 of 25
Holocaust

Introducing the Unit

Students develop a contract establishing a reflective classroom community as they prepare to explore the historical case study of this unit.

Lesson 2 of 25
Holocaust

Exploring Identity

Students identify the social and cultural factors that help shape our identities by analyzing firsthand reflections and creating personal identity charts.

Lesson 3 of 25
Holocaust

Stereotypes and "Single Stories"

Students create working definitions of stereotype as they examine the human behavior of applying categories to people and things.

Lesson 4 of 25
Holocaust

Universe of Obligation

Students learn a new concept, universe of obligation, and use it to analyze the ways that their society designates who is deserving of respect and caring.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 1:

Introducing and Dissecting the Writing Prompt

Students begin to understand and stake out a preliminary position in response to the assessment writing prompt.

Lesson 5 of 25
Antisemitism & Religious Intolerance

The Roots and Impact of Antisemitism

Students explore the long history of discrimination against Jews and come to understand how anti-Judaism was transformed into antisemitism in the nineteenth century.

Lesson 6 of 25
The Armenian Genocide

The Rise of Nationalism and the Collapse of the Ottoman Empire

Students turn their attention to the collapse of the Ottoman Empire and the emergence of a strong current of ethno-nationalism rooted in Turkish identity.

Lesson 7 of 25
The Armenian Genocide

Genocide under the Cover of War

Students learn about the events and choices of the Armenian Genocide and explore the consequences of the genocide from the perspective of survivors.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 2:

Introducing Evidence Logs

After learning about the Armenian Genocide, students reflect on the writing prompt a second time by adding a historical lense.

Lesson 8 of 25
The Armenian Genocide

Nationalism and the Aftermath of World War I

Students consider the ways in which World War I intensified people’s loyalty to their country and resentment toward others perceived as a threat.

Lesson 9 of 25
Holocaust

The Weimar Republic

Students reflect on the idea of democracy as they analyze the politics, economics, and culture of Germany during the period of the Weimar Republic.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 3:

Adding to Evidence Logs, 1 of 4

Students incorporate new evidence from the history of the Weimar era into the position they are developing.

Lesson 10 of 25
Holocaust

The Rise of the Nazi Party

Students examine how choices made by individuals and groups contributed to the rise of the Nazi Party in the 1920s and 1930s.

Lesson 11 of 25
Holocaust

European Jewish Life before World War II

Students analyze images and film that convey the richness of Jewish life across Europe at the time of the Nazis’ ascension to power.

Lesson 12 of 25
Holocaust

Dismantling Democracy

Students examine the steps the Nazis took to replace democracy with dictatorship and draw conclusions about the values and institutions that make democracy possible.

Lesson 13 of 25
Holocaust

Do You Take the Oath

Students consider the choices and reasoning of individual Germans who stayed quiet or spoke up during the first few years of Nazi rule.

Lesson 14 of 25
Holocaust

Laws and the National Community

Students are introduced to the Nazis’ idea of a “national community” and examine how the Nazis used the Nuremberg Laws to define who belonged.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 4:

Adding to Evidence Logs, 2 of 4

Students consider how what they've learned about the rise of the Nazi Party influences their thinking about the essay prompt and practice making inferences.

Lesson 15 of 25
Holocaust

Power of Propaganda

Students analyze several examples of Nazi propaganda and consider how the Nazis used media to influence the thoughts, feelings, and actions of individual Germans.

Lesson 16 of 25
Holocaust

Youth and the National Community

Students learn about the experiences of people in Nazi Germany through a variety of firsthand accounts and identify the range of choices that they faced.

Lesson 17 of 25
Holocaust

Kristallnacht

Students learn about the violent pogroms of Kristallnacht by watching a short documentary and then reflecting on eyewitness testimonies.

Lesson 18 of 25
Holocaust

Responding to a Refugee Crisis

Students think about the responsibilities of governments as they consider how countries around the world responded to the European Jews trying to escape Nazi Germany.

Lesson 19 of 25
Holocaust

Race and Space

Students examine the Nazi ideology of “race and space” and the role it played in Germany’s aggression toward other nations, groups, and individuals.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 5:

Adding to Evidence Logs, 3 of 4

Students review the documents and videos from previous lessons and consider what information supports, expands, or challenges their thinking about the essay.

Lesson 20 of 25
Holocaust

The Holocaust: Bearing Witness

Students are introduced to the enormity of the crimes committed during the Holocaust and look closely at stories of a few individuals who were targeted by Nazi brutality.

Lesson 21 of 25
Holocaust

The Holocaust: Range of Responses

Students deepen their examination of human behavior during the Holocaust by analyzing and discussing the range of choices available to individuals, groups, and nations.

Lesson 22 of 25
Holocaust

Justice and Judgment after the Holocaust

Students grapple with the meaning of justice and the purpose of trials as they learn how the Allies responded to the atrocities of Nazi Germany.

Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 6:

Adding to Evidence Logs, 4 of 4

Students reflect on, gather evidence for, and discuss the unit writing prompt in its entirety.

Lesson 23 of 25
The Armenian Genocide

Confronting Genocide Denial

Students explore some of the causes and consequences of denying the Armenian Genocide and reflect on the role of public art to commemorate difficult histories.

Lesson 24 of 25
The Armenian Genocide

Survivor Testimony and the Legacy of Memory

Students deepen their thinking about memory and identity by reflecting on the stories of Holocaust and Armenian Genocide survivors and their descendants.

Lesson 25 of 25
Holocaust

Choosing to Participate

Students use the “levers of power” framework to identify ways they can bring about positive change in their communities.

Final Assessment

Topic

Holocaust
The Armenian Genocide
Step 7:

Refining the Thesis and Finalizing Evidence Logs

Students reflect on the unit as a whole and begin to write a strong thesis statement for their essay.

Search Our Global Collection

Everything you need to get started teaching your students about racism, antisemitism and prejudice.