Indian Mascot Controversy in Colorado
Colorado State Senator Suzanne Williams introduced a bill in January 2010 that would require public high schools or charter high schools in the state of Colorado “that use an American Indian mascot to either stop using it or gain approval of its use from the Colorado Commission of Indian Affairs,” ReporterHerald.com writes. The Denver Post quotes Williams as saying that she “introduced this bill because [she] feel[s] very strongly that we need a conversation about the subtle discrimination between races and cultures.” Her proposal met great resistance from a number of the 36 schools the bill would affect. Loveland High School’s Indian mascot was originally chosen based on the results of an essay contest in which the winner said Indians stood for “ ‘bravery, loyalty, patriotism and dauntless pride,’ ” ReporterHerald.com states. The high school’s athletic director, Devin Anderson, said “ ‘we feel we can use [the Indian mascot] to the point of teaching diversity and tolerance.’ ” One newspaper sided with Williams, stating that “ ‘It’s time for the Red to go,’ adding ‘It’s unfortunate Williams even had to introduce the legislation,’ ” The Denver Channel reports. According to The Denver Post, Williams recently announced that she plans to withdraw the bill, “saying she has already achieved her goal of igniting community discussions over whether the mascots are appropriate.”
- What is a mascot? What is the purpose of a mascot? Why might some find Indian mascots offensive? Can you think of other mascots that might be considered offensive?
- Colorado State Senator Suzanne Williams is quoted in The Denver Post as saying that she introduced the bill because she feels “ ‘we need a conversation about the subtle discrimination between races and cultures.’ ” How might the use of an Indian as a mascot be seen as a subtle form of discrimination? Loveland High School’s Athletic Director Devin Anderson said “ ‘we feel we can use [the Indian mascot] to the point of teaching diversity and tolerance,’ ” ReporterHerald.com writes. How can you reconcile Williams and Anderson’s statements? Can an Indian mascot be both a symbol of discrimination and a teaching point for diversity and tolerance? If so, how?
- Loveland High School claims to have chosen the Indian as their mascot because Indians stand for
“ ‘bravery, loyalty, patriotism and dauntless pride,’ ” ReporterHerald.com states. Do good intentions make it okay to have an Indian mascot? Could a mascot chosen with the best of intentions still be offensive to some? - How do you decide if something is offensive? Have you ever been in a situation where you were offended by something, but someone else was not? How could a situation or statement offend some people and not others?
- Is it up to Native Americans to say that they find Indian mascots offensive? Can having Indian mascots be seen as offensive even if Native Americans do not speak out?


