This lesson addresses the following essential questions:
In this lesson students will...
Selected readings from Crimes Against Humanity and Civilization [1]:
Acquitting the Assassin, pp. 165-166
Video:
The Armenian Genocide [2] (Two Cats Productions/Oregon Public Broadcasting)
Warm up:
Ask students to define the word justice in their journal. Then have them think about a time when they felt like a victim or when they were treated unfairly. What would have needed to happen for there to be justice in this situation? Ask students to share their responses. Now ask students to consider the questions, "For there to be justice, what would need to happen? Who should be held accountable? Who would we need to be involved?" Have students brainstorm answers to these questions.
Main activity:
1. Show the class an excerpt of the film The Armenian Genocide which focuses on the post-war trials in Turkey (minutes 34:00-37:23) To help students pick up details, you can pass out a sheet with key questions. Suggested key questions include:
You might have to show the clip two or three times to allow students to answer all of these questions. You could also divide the questions among the class so that students only have to listen for answers to two or three questions. After showing the clip, students can share their answers with the class. Ultimately, all students should end this activity knowing basic facts about post-war trials in Turkey.
2. "Take a stand" Activity: The next activity requires students to synthesize their beliefs about justice and their understanding of the Armenian Genocide, especially the events following the Armenian Genocide.
Before you begin the "Take a Stand" activity, ask students to read "Acquitting the Assassin," pp. 165-166. Or, you can summarize this reading for them. The story or Soghomon Tehlirian is also included in the film The Armenian Genocide (36:00-36:44). After students are familiar with the facts surrounding the murder or TalaatBey and the trial of Soghomon Tehlirian, ask students if they strongly agree, agree, disagree or strongly disagree with the following statement: The not guilty verdict in the trial of Soghomon Tehlirian contributed to the cause of justice. Then begin the "Take a Stand" Activity described above. Below are other "Take a Stand" statements you might also include in this lesson:
Follow through:
As a final debrief of the concept of justice, you can ask students to connect their understanding of the Armenian Genocide to their own experience with justice. Prompts: What is justice? Is it the same as punishment? Who is responsible for making sure that justice is served? How might perpetrators or bystanders view justice differently than the victims or witnesses?
Students can write about two episodes in their life: a time when they felt like the victim of injustice and a time when they might have been a bystander or perpetrator of injustice. Ask students to describe what "justice" would have looked like after each of these situations. Do their ideas of justice change when approaching the situation from the perspective of the perpetrator or bystander as opposed to from the perspective of the victim?
Students can write a persuasive essay elaborating on any of the "take a stand" comments. Or, they can compare what actually happened after the Armenian Genocide to their initial answer to the question, "For there to be justice for Armenians, what would need to happen? Who would we need to be involved?"
Links:
[1] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/publications/ag
[2] http://www2.facinghistory.org/campus/reslib.nsf/llvideos/Armenian Genocide, The?OpenDocument