Do you have a link we can include?
Submit a link here.
What
do young people learn about each other when they grow up amidst
violence and conflict? What does it take to move beyond the myth,
mistrust, and misinformation that can become part of the cycle of
conflict? In a climate of fear is it possible to see the world beyond
the stark contrasts of "us against them" and "those that are with us
versus those that against us?" And, if you are able to bring young
people together for dialogue, how can their experiences be harnessed to
create momentum for peace.
Raya Kalisman is the founder and director
of the Center for Humanistic Education at the Ghetto Fighters' Museum
in Israel. Since the founding of the state of Israel, Israelis have
been under the constant threat of violence from their neighbors. At the
same time, many Palestinians argue that they have been displaced by the
Jewish state and feel that they are not treated as equal citizens.
Young people from both groups have little opportunity to get to know
each other. For the most part Jews and Arabs (Moslems, Christians, and
Druze) live apart from each other. Most Israeli schools are segregated
by religion and language. The Center for Humanistic Education hopes to
create a space for young people to come together. Founded in 1996, the
center aims to promote respect, learning, and understanding among Jews
and Arabs.
Here is how Ms. Kalisman describes her program's approach:
We, as an
educational center, are committed to the humanistic vision that is
comprised of, firstly-a worldview that aspires to fostering human
liberty and expanding the latent abilities of the individual, and to a
moral code that places human dignity and well being above everything,
and that it should not be harmed in the name of religious, nationalist
or economic ideologies. Secondly-we believe in the political
translation of this point of view into a democratic, tolerant and
enlightened society, based on human equality, moral sensitivity and
social solidarity.
At the multicultural encounters provided
by the Center for Humanistic Education, there are discussions on the
ways to expand social equality, to fight against racism, and to
safeguard human and minority rights. In a joint activity for Jews and
Arabs that fosters interpersonal relationships, the participants learn
and discuss the fate of the Jewish and Palestinian people, and past and
present events in Arab-Jewish relations in Israel, in order to learn to
accept the others' narrative, to identify with their pain, and to work
for reconciliation between the two nations. Stepping into somebody
else's shoes is definitely one of the techniques we use frequently but
carefully. We believe it is a very important skill for our graduates,
although we realize it is a very difficult one and not every one is
able to use it.
Jewish and Arab staff members jointly
teach the multicultural seminars, which are attended by students who
make serious commitment to attend each session in addition to academic
commitments from school. On April 30, 2002-in the midst of violence and
acts of terrorism-young graduates of the program held a reunion and
issued a statement. It read:
For you, for me, for us. How are we? (In Hebrew this statement also means, "How is our peace?").
Not mine, or yours, but ours. Is it really our peace? At this point in time can we really turn it into our peace?
Many of us, Jews and Arabs, adhere to the
feeling of being a victim, and so automatically justify acts
perpetrated by our side, and level accusations at the other side.
We are a group of Arab and Jewish youth
who work together in the framework of the Center for Humanistic
Education at the Ghetto Fighters' Museum. Together we studied the
emotionally charged and painful history of both our nations. Here we
learned to listen to the other side, and we discovered that they had
problems we knew nothing about. Today we understand that, despite the
difficulty, we must let go of our personal pain, fear, and desire for
revenge, and not allow the scars of the past to rule our lives. We must
continue moving forward, based on the faith that will lead each and
every one of us to act: we will continue to meet and talk in order to
understand each other.
From our limited experience as teenagers,
we understand today that in order to understand you need to look at the
person in front of you not as a Jew, not as an Arab, not as a
Palestinian, American, Afghani, or Rwandan, but as a human being-as
Shachar, Morad, Amira, Sachar, Raja, and Reut. Let us not give in to
despair, let us hang on in these difficult moments, in the hope that
ordinary people will be able to overcome the threatening extremism and
hatred.
In the story of the Tower of Babel, G-d
commanded people to speak in different languages so that they would not
understand each other. We pray that the day will come when people again
speak the same language and begin to rebuild the tower... the tower of
peace.
This is not an attempt to change the
world, it is an attempt to find a common language, to look people
straight in the eye and ask: "Hey brother, how are you?"
Connections
In the midst of violence, what does it take to recognize the humanity of the other?
How do you learn about others with
different experiences from your own. Has your education introduced you
to the lives and experiences of others? Is it the role of education to
"humanize the other"? What obstacles prevent people from getting to
know the "other"?
As you read Ms. Kalisman's description of
the program, what words stand out? What values does she hope to impart?
Why are those values vital to a vibrant democracy?
What does it take to turn positive experiences with "the other" into momentum for peace? How can that momentum be sustained?
David Netzer, a colleague of Ms. Kalisman's at the Center for Humanistic Education writes:
The capacity to hate and destroy is
nourished by the mechanism of de-humanization of the "Other". That's
what makes that "other" an "enemy". It's true about an ethnically mixed
neighborhood as it is about a war between two nations. What we try to
do in our Center is bring this mechanism to our students' awareness and
understanding, with the goal of diffusing it. I believe that humanizing
the other is the basis for coexistential attitude. We try to apply this
approach through the intensive interpersonal encounters we conduct.
Other means can be literature and art in general; personal testimonies
from conflict-sites; exercises in "stepping to the Other's shoes";
studying history through the prism of the Individual as opposed to the
Collective; holding internet conversations like this one; etc. There
are many ways and means to this main goal: look at the other - and see
yourself.
Manar Fawakhry, an Israeli Arab and a
Muslim, is a graduate of the Center for Humanistic Education. After
graduating from the program she took a job at the center. Despite her
enthusiasm for the work, she often finds herself the subject of
unwanted scrutiny. She explains
I work, by choice, at the Center for
Humanistic Education at the Ghetto Fighters' House. As an Arab woman
and a member of the staff at the Center that teaches about the
Holocaust ... my situation is not at all a simple one. Here are two
examples of incidents, which occurred at the beginning of this academic
year. On a visit to two friends, I was asked, half jokingly: "Haven't
you been called ‘Dirty Arab' yet, at the Center where you work?" Even
though intended as a joke, I understood clearly the thrust of the barb.
The same day, shopping in my village for a staff meeting that evening
at the Center, I met another friend in the street who asked me directly
if I was working at the Ghetto Fighters' House. Answering that I was,
she fixed me with a gaze of disappointment.
Consider Ms. Fawakhry's decision to work
at the Center for Humanistic Education. What risks and challenges does
she face as she tries to make a difference? Reflect on a choice you
have made in an effort to create positive change. What was it? What
challenges did you face?
Note: The media selections posted in Facing Today do not necessarily represent the views of Facing History and Ourselves.