According
to the BBC World Service there are 300,000 child soldiers fighting in
conflicts around the world. Many of those children were recruited to
fight when they were as young as ten years old. Sam Gbaydee Doe, a
Christian Minister and the founder and executive director of the West
African Network for Peacebuilding has worked with child soldiers in
Liberia and Sierra Leone in an effort to help them rebuild their lives.
That work has been particularly difficult because he is working in a
part of the world that has been ripped apart by civil war. A recent
Human Rights Watch report on child soldiers in Liberia explains:
Since August 2003, a peace agreement and
cease-fire has stopped the fighting. Gbaydee Doe learned that one of
the greatest challenges in working with child soldiers is to help them
rebuild their identities. He wrote about his experiences during a 1998
cease-fire.
During the 1998 cease-fire Gbaydee Doe
worked to reintegrate child soldiers back into their communities. In a
letter to a colleague, he described the transformation that he saw in
the children:
Those experiences have had a profound
effect on how Gbaydee Doe sees the work. He believes "our civilization
should be measured by what we do to our children." Despite Liberia's
long history of violence, Gbaydee Doe remains hopeful that peace is
possible but it will take more than legal and political settlements.
There is no environment that can help
transform violence except an environment that is characterized by love,
by tolerance, by absolute acceptance of the person going
beyond...behavioral and attitudinal limitations and beginning to see the
God in that person.5
Connections
What does it take to turn children into
unquestioning soldiers? How were the identities of children destroyed
and later recreated in that process?
Gbaydee Doe asks, "Why did the warlords
take the renaming of children seriously?" Many children - from child
soldiers to gang members - who are involved in violence take on new
names. Others become avatars online and take on new names and new
identities. What is the relationship between a name and identity?
Another aspect of the recruitment of
child soldiers was the way that warlords "destroyed every earlier
relationship which defined the children." What are the consequences of
destroying relationships between a child, their community, friends, and
relatives?
Gbaydee Doe notes the ritual of naming
children in Liberia as a way of saying something about a child's
identity. What are the other rituals used to condition children to
violence? Are their rituals you know about that are used to promote
tolerance and non-violence?
How can a community educate for peace in
the midst of violence? Gbaydee Doe believes that legal and political
solutions to violence are insufficient in themselves. He explains:
There is no environment that can help
transform violence except an environment that is characterized by love,
by tolerance, by absolute acceptance of the person going
beyond...behavioral and attitudinal limitations and beginning to see the
God in that person.
What would such an environment look like? Why is it so hard to achieve?
Gbaydee Doe believes "our civilization
should be measured by what we do to our children." How is that
sentiment reflected in the laws, customs, and practices of a society?
One international effort to protect children is the United Nations
Convention on the Rights of the Child. Visit http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu3/b/k2crc.htm [4] to read the convention. Consider the way that the articles of the convention have been addressed or ignored in your society?
U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan
believes that child soldiers in Sierra Leone should be subject to war
crime prosecution for their actions during the civil war. Consider the
situation of child soldiers that Gbaydee Doe describes. Should they be
held accountable for their war crimes? Are there times when the need
for accountability gets in the way of efforts to build peace? If so,
should we then disregard the rights of the victim? Is peace for the
community more important than justice for an individual? If we let
these perpetrators of some of the most savage violence off because of
their age, what precedent do we set?
Arn Chorn-Pond, a former child soldier,
survivor of the Cambodian Genocide, and human rights activist. For the
past 20 years he has worked every day to rebuild that which was
destroyed during the genocide - reestablishing bridges between the
young and old, respecting traditional Cambodian culture, and giving
voice to traditional musicians who were among the first victims of the
genocide. His life story, interwoven with his current work in Cambodia,
is told in the film The Flute Player. The film is available from the
Facing History and Ourselves Resource Library. For more information
visit www.thefluteplayer.net or www.facinghistory.org.
In 1993 Sam Gbaydee Doe's village in
Liberia was destroyed during a civil war. During the attacks many of
his relatives were killed. Three years later he was forced to flee his
country. After leaving home Gbaydee Doe studied conflict transformation
at Eastern Mennonite University in the United States, a program that
aims not just to find a resolution to conflict but also to change the
dynamics of the society in which the conflict erupted. As a
peacebuilder he wants to break the cycle of fear, violence, and
revenge. "I can be victimized," Gbaydee Doe has said, "but it is clear
to me that I cannot be a victim. Victimhood is a place of helplessness.
Recognizing that someone has victimized me, I try to think about how I
can move on." Once you have been victimized, what does it take to move
on? What kind of skills and support can help facilitate the process?
For more information on Sam Gbaydee Doe
and the challenges faced by several other peacebuilders across the
world visit the archive of the Facing History and Ourselves online
forum Engaging the Future: Religion, Human Rights and Conflict
Resolution at www.facinghistory.org/future.
Gbaydee Doe explains that children in
Liberia were expected to live up to the meaning behind their names. He
writes that, "A child who was named ‘Dirty Ways' was expected to be
nasty in dealing with civilians or his ‘enemies.' A ‘Rambo' was
supposed to be as brave and adventurous as Hollywood's Sylvester
Stallone." The book The Bear That Wasn't, a modern fable, explores the
ways in which the expectations of others influence how people see
themselves. It is available from the Facing History and Ourselves
resource library and is excerpted in Facing History and Ourselves:
Holocaust and Human Behavior.
Many psychologists have studied the way
human beings are conditioned for violence. Among the most famous are
Stanley Milgram who worked on obedience to authority and Philip
Zimbardo whose prison experiment investigated "what happens when you
put good people in an evil place?" Zimbardo's prison experiment is
documented on line. Visit his web site at http://www.zimbardo.com [5]. Videos of both experiments are available from the Facing History and Ourselves resource library.
Several other resources from the Facing
History and Ourselves Resource Library touch on themes reflected in
this reading including:
· If the Mango Tree Could Speak - This
documentary about children and war in South America offers a glimpse of
ten boys and girls growing up in the midst of war in Guatemala and El
Salvador. The children speak with honesty about war and peace, justice,
ethnic identity, marriage, and friendship. They share their dreams and
hopes, pain and loss.
· Monsta - An interview with Cody Scott,
a former gang member from Los Angeles, and author of the memoir
Monster. He describes what led him to be a gang member and his new
revolutionary politics.
· Waging Peace - This film documents the
"Tomorrow's Leaders" conference that was held in Venice during the
summer of 1995. The conference was sponsored by the Elie Wiesel
Foundation for Humanity and co-facilitated by Facing History and
Ourselves. It brought together thirty young people from around the
world who documented the ways they had harnessed hope, expressed
outrage, and made a positive difference in their community or nation.
Many of the participants were from war-torn nations, or lived in
communities divided by generations of ethnic hatred. The film shares
the conversations between the participants as they struggled with
issues of democracy, social change, personal identity, and the roots of
conflict both within their regions and in other parts of the world.
Links:
[1] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/facingtoday/submit-a-story
[2] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/facingtoday/engaging-future-learning-fro
[3] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/facingtoday/engaging-future-listening-ot
[4] http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu3/b/k2crc.htm
[5] http://www.zimbardo.com/
[6] http://www.everydaygandhis.com/doe.html
[7] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/facingtoday/engaging-future-learning-fro
[8] http://www.facinghistory.org/resources/facingtoday/engaging-future-listening-ot